How much a target delivers
In general, targets do work. Specific, difficult targets get more than “do your best”: in a line of 100 salespeople, the median salesperson on a team with a target goes from passing 50 to passing 66 to 79. That is MeContaí’s calculation, based on effects of 0.42 to 0.80 standard deviations (how to read that number). The result depends on the context: the team believing the target can be reached, committing to it, knowing the reason for it and seeing its progress.
What the research shows about sales targets
Locke and Latham (2002) brought together 35 years of studies on goal-setting theory: more than 100 tasks and more than 40,000 people, in at least eight countries, in the lab and in the field. For anyone holding a team to a target, three findings matter:
- A clear, demanding number gets more than “do your best”. An effect of 0.42 to 0.80 standard deviations in the 1990 reviews of studies cited in the article.
- The harder the target, the more effort and results, in general. An effect of 0.52 to 0.82 standard deviations.
- A target with feedback works better than a target on its own. If the team doesn’t know how it is doing, it can’t adjust.
For stores with several salespeople, Kleingeld, van Mierlo and Arends (2011) brought together studies on group goals. A specific, difficult target got more than a vague one, with an effect of 0.80 standard deviations across 23 comparisons. In 6 comparisons, when each person pursued only their own result in an interdependent group, the group did worse (−1.75 standard deviations): a sign that calls for caution.
How to read the numbers in the studies (standard deviation)
Each study measured something different: units produced, time, sales. To compare them, researchers use a common yardstick, the standard deviation: the typical gap between one salesperson and another in the same group. Saying a target had an effect of 0.42 means it pushes the team up by 0.42 of that typical gap. Because that number says little on its own, MeContaí translates it into a position in a line.
Line up 100 salespeople who were only told “do your best”, from the one who sold least to the one who sold most. Now put the median salesperson from a team with a specific, difficult target into that line. Passing a salesperson means having sold more than they did. With no effect from the target, they pass 50. With an effect of 0.42, the smallest measured in the studies, they pass 66. With 0.80, the largest, they pass 79. The calculation is MeContaí’s and assumes that most people sell close to the average.
Dark: the median salesperson on the team with a target passes this salesperson.
Light: they don’t.
This holds for a target that is difficult but achievable. If the team thinks it can’t be done, the effect shrinks or disappears.
What this number is not. Passing 66 of 100 is a position in a ranking. It doesn’t say by what percentage sales go up.
Converting standard deviations into positions assumes a bell curve: a few people sell very little, a few sell a lot, and most are close to the average. That assumption is MeContaí’s, not the studies’. If your team’s sales don’t follow that shape, the positions change.
When a target stops working
The same review points to three situations in which the effect shrinks or disappears:
- A target beyond capacity. When you hit the limit of what the business can deliver, results level off or drop.
- A target without commitment. If the team stops committing to a very difficult target, results also level off or drop.
- A target imposed without the reason. A target set by the owner works as well as one agreed on with the team, if the reason is explained. Stated curtly, it gets less.
What all three have in common is the team believing it can’t get there. Effort is costly, and people only spend it when it seems worth it.
A critical review (Ordóñez and others, 2009) warns of the side effects of poorly calibrated targets: narrow focus, distorted risk-taking, more unethical behavior and less intrinsic motivation.
An example: the same target in two versions
Loja Exemplo is a fictional burger restaurant that sells an average of R$ 60,000 a month. Target A, an achievable challenge, is R$ 60,000 × 1.10 = R$ 66,000, and the owner explains to the team why it exists. Target B, an impossible one, is R$ 60,000 × 2 = R$ 120,000, with no explanation and no change to the operation. Target B goes beyond what the business can deliver, and the team loses its commitment. What separates the two versions is whether the team believes it can be done.
Video summary (in Portuguese) Do sales targets really work? Watch the Short on YouTubeDoes tracking the target help? What 138 studies say
Harkin and others (2016) brought together 138 randomized studies on progress monitoring, in which one group was encouraged to track its progress and another was not. Those who tracked reached their goal more often, with an effect of 0.40 standard deviations: the average person ended up ahead of 66 out of every 100 people who didn’t track.
The effect was 0.55 when tracking was public, versus 0.19 when it was private, and 0.43 when progress was recorded in writing, versus 0.29 when it wasn’t. The limitation: almost all the studies are about health, such as diet, exercise and blood pressure.
One way to give that feedback is a daily message in the team’s WhatsApp group with yesterday’s result, today’s target and the month’s scoreboard. Here is a sample:
Your performance summary
Loja Exemplo · Wednesday
Yesterday’s result: R$ 2,350
Today’s target: R$ 2,200
Month’s scoreboard: R$ 31,000 of R$ 66,000
Fictional example with made-up figures.
To build the target, see how to set a sales target; to split the total across the days, see how to calculate a salesperson’s target.
What MeContaí observes, without a study
This section is not research: it is what the MeContaí team notices in clients who get their results every day, without any measurement.
Businesses that give salespeople and managers weekly feedback on the target seem to do better when they add daily tracking. Having a target helps; seeing the result every day seems to help even more. People who are bolder tend to look for solutions when they are below target; more cautious people are sometimes alarmed by the numbers or feel they are being watched.
What to do with the research in your team’s target
Five recommendations from MeContaí:
- Set a number instead of asking for “your best” (when to set a sales target).
- Choose a challenge the team can reach (what a salesperson’s target should be).
- Explain the reason for the target before holding people to it.
- Show progress often. In the studies, the effect was larger when tracking was public; agree on the format with the team.
- If your salespeople share a counter, look at the team’s target too.
Sources and reference date
See the four sources and when they were consulted
Research on goals:
- Locke, E. A. and Latham, G. P. (2002). Building a practically useful theory of goal setting and task motivation: a 35-year odyssey. American Psychologist, 57(9), 705-717
- Kleingeld, A. and others (2011). The effect of goal setting on group performance: a meta-analysis. Journal of Applied Psychology, 96(6), 1289-1304
- Harkin, B. and others (2016). Does monitoring goal progress promote goal attainment? A meta-analysis of the experimental evidence. Psychological Bulletin, 142(2), 198-229
- Ordóñez, L. D. and others (2009). Goals gone wild: the systematic side effects of overprescribing goal setting. Academy of Management Perspectives, 23(1), 6-16
Locke and Latham consulted on Oct 21, 2026 (figures checked against the article on Oct 22, 2026); Harkin, in the full text of the article, and the others, in their abstracts, on Oct 23, 2026.
Newsletter · every Tuesday
Get articles like this one in your inbox
One issue a week on everyday retail topics. Each topic comes with a summary and a link to the full article.
How much of this month’s target is already sitting in your system?
The Recoverable Revenue Diagnosis looks at the last 12 months of sales in your customer base and shows how many customers bought and didn’t come back. It is a starting point for setting a target the team can reach.
Request a diagnosis of my operation
Prefer to talk now? Start a conversation with the MeContaí team directly on WhatsApp.
Chat on WhatsApp