A public discount is open to everyone; a discount for your customer base goes only to people who are already customers, through a direct message. When a business decides to run a discount, the most common path is the first one: the price drops on the website, the post goes out on social media, sometimes an ad runs on the radio or in the newspaper, and anyone can take advantage of it.
The second path is to offer the discount only to your customer base. Each one has a different effect on the average ticket (the average value of each order), on sales for the period and on the kind of customer it brings in.
- A public discount tends to lower the average ticket and to bring in people who came only for the price.
- A discount for your customer base applies to few of the month’s orders, so it barely moves the average ticket, and it speaks to people who already know your business.
- The suggestion is to split your investment and, when you think about a discount, to test it with your customer base first.
What happens with a public discount
A public discount is a discount open to everyone, on your website, on social media, on the radio or in the newspaper.
The average ticket drops. If most of the period’s orders go out with a discount, the period’s average goes down with them.
Many people come in only for the price. The campaign brings in new customers, and that is good. But many of them were drawn by the lower price. When the price goes back to normal, not all of them stay. So before celebrating the number of new customers, it is worth tracking how many make a second purchase.
Then there is reach. On Instagram, people see the post for a second or two and move on to the next one. On the radio, the ad shares airtime with many others. You talk to a lot of people, but to few people who already have a relationship with your brand.
What a discount for your customer base is
A discount for your customer base is a discount exclusive to customers, offered only to people who have already bought from you. You choose a group, send the message on WhatsApp (or through another channel that reaches the person directly) and the discount is valid only for those who received it. It can arrive as a coupon exclusive to customers or as a lower price only for that group.
In MeContaí’s post-sale work, we choose that group from the purchase history: the date of the last purchase and how many times the customer has bought, using the business’s repeat purchase time as a reference.
In practice, it is like rewarding customers for being customers. And since you are talking to people who have already bought, the chance that they buy again is higher than the chance of convincing someone who has never heard of you.
| Aspect | Public discount | Discount for your customer base |
|---|---|---|
| Who gets it | Everyone | Only existing customers |
| Average ticket for the month | Tends to drop | Barely changes |
| Who buys | Many come for the price | People who already know the business |
| How it arrives | A few seconds, among other ads | A direct message, by name |
Why a discount for your customer base barely changes the average ticket
A business usually has a steady flow of orders during the month. When the discount goes only to a group from your customer base, it applies to a small slice of those orders, and the others keep the regular price. That is why even a big discount barely shows up in the month’s average. In an illustrative example, with orders of the same value, a 20% discount used in 80 out of every 100 orders lowers the month’s average ticket by about 16%; used in 15 out of every 100, by about 3%.
- Public discount, used in 80 out of every 100 orders
- −16% in the average ticket
- Discount for your customer base, used in 15 out of every 100 orders
- −3% in the average ticket
Illustrative example, with orders of the same value. Not a promise of results.
How much a discount for your customer base can move sales for the period
Picture a fictional store, Example Store, with about 20,000 customers in its base. It picks 1,000 customers for a weekend campaign, on WhatsApp only. If 80 of them buy on a weekend when the store usually sells 200 orders, the weekend closes with 280 orders, 40% more. The numbers are fictional and vary from business to business.
- A regular weekend
- 200
- With the campaign for 1,000 customers from the base
- 280
Fictional example. The numbers vary from business to business.
Some of these people would have bought anyway. To know what the campaign really brought in, compare with a similar group that didn’t receive the message. Lesson 5 of the WhatsApp Offers training shows how to make that comparison.
What the campaign brings beyond the sale
When customers come back, they use your product again. If it’s a restaurant, they eat the meal again. If it’s a store, they walk into the store or visit the website and see the products again. Each return strengthens how they remember the brand and raises the chance of another purchase.
Those who didn’t buy also learned that there was a campaign made for them. The brand showed up for them again, even without a sale.
To build the offer with a headline, benefit, deadline and action, the post On WhatsApp, the offer decides whether the customer comes back shows the five parts.
How to split your investment between public advertising and your customer base
Keep advertising. Public advertising brings in new people, and your business needs that. Just don’t put 100% of your investment there, or 100% into your customer base.
When the decision is to give a discount or lower a price, offer it to your customer base first.
If the campaign works there, you already know what to expect before opening it to everyone.
- Test with your customer baseA small group of customers gets the offer on WhatsApp, with an end date.
- Read the resultCompare the people who received it with a similar group that didn’t receive the message.
- Open it to everyoneIf it worked with your customer base, take the discount to your website and social media, already knowing what to expect.
Three things to watch when you run the campaign
- Start with a small group. A few hundred customers are enough to show whether the offer works.
- Make it clear that it’s for the people who received it. Customers need to understand that the benefit is theirs, and why.
- Set an end date. A deadline helps people decide and lets you measure the result of the campaign.
Send it only to people who have already been in touch with your business and agree to receive messages. Anyone who asks to stop receiving them should be removed from the list.
Frequently asked questions
What is a public discount?
It is a discount open to everyone: on your website, on social media, on the radio or in the newspaper. Anyone can use it, customer or not.
What is a discount for your customer base?
It is a discount offered only to people who have already bought from you, through a direct message such as WhatsApp. It is valid only for the group that received it.
Why does a discount for your customer base barely change the average ticket?
Because it applies to a small share of the month’s orders. The other orders keep the regular price, and the month’s average hardly changes.
Does a public discount bring in new customers?
It does, but many come only for the price and don’t come back when the discount ends. It is worth measuring how many of those customers make a second purchase.
Should I stop running public promotions?
No. The idea is to split your investment between public advertising and your customer base and, when you think about a discount, to offer it to your customer base first before opening it to everyone.
How do I know whether the discount for my customer base worked?
Compare the people who received the message with a similar group that didn’t. The difference in purchases between the two groups shows what the campaign brought in on top. Lesson 5 of the WhatsApp Offers training shows how to make that comparison.
Can I send promotions to my customers on WhatsApp?
Yes, as long as you only send them to people who have already been in touch with your business and agree to receive messages. Anyone who asks to stop receiving them should be removed from the list.
Do discounts for longtime customers work?
Longtime customers already know your business and your product, so the chance that they buy again is higher than the chance of convincing someone who has never heard of you. Results vary from business to business, so it is worth testing with a small group before opening it to everyone.