Customer retention · · 5 min read

Why the same message for your whole customer base doesn't work

The three customer groups that need different conversations, and the message for each one.

Do you send the same message to your entire customer base? It's the fastest route: write one message, select the whole list and hit send. The promotion reaches the customer who buys every week, the person who bought once a year ago and the person who only asked for a quote. Everyone reads the same thing.

The problem is that these people are not at the same point with your business. And when the message is the same for all of them, it ends up truly working for almost none.

In short
  • Customers with different histories respond differently to the same campaign.
  • Three groups are enough to change the conversation: people who bought only once, people who buy all the time, and people who used to buy and stopped.
  • All three come from the sales history you already have, using a spreadsheet of the last 12 months.

People who already know you respond differently

In a real case at a retail chain, MeContaí tracked one campaign sent to customers with different purchase histories.

How many bought, for every 100 who received the campaign
Had never bought before
fewer than 2 in 100 bought
Had already bought eight times or more
46 in 100 bought

A real case, not a promise of results. The numbers vary from business to business.

Same campaign, same period. What changed was each person's relationship with the store.

The takeaway is not to talk only to your best customers. It's that each group needs a different conversation. When everyone gets the same message, the loyal customer receives a generic offer that ignores their history, and the new customer receives a text that has nothing to do with where they are right now. Talking to everyone the same way wastes both. When the campaign is a discount, the post Public discount or a discount for your customer base? shows why it pays to test it first with a group from your customer base.

The three groups

You don't need dozens of segments to get started. Three groups are enough to change the conversation, and all of them come from the sales history you already have.

Group 1People who bought only once

In many businesses this is the largest group, and the easiest to lose. The person got to know your business but hasn't yet built the habit of coming back.

What to do: invite them to a second purchase. Ask whether everything went well with what they bought and offer to get it for them again.

Message template
Hi, [name]! It's [your name] from [business]. It's been [X days] since you bought [product]. Did everything go well? If you'd like another one, I'll set it aside for you.

Group 2People who buy all the time

There aren't many of them, but they often bring in a large share of revenue. They are also often the ones who get the least attention, because “they'll come back anyway”.

What to do: recognize them. Thank them, show that you know they're a regular and let them hear about what's new first. A discount isn't required. Attention is.

Message template
Hi, [name]! You're one of the customers who come back to [business] the most, and I wanted to thank you. [New product] just came in and you were the first person I thought of.

Group 3People who used to buy and stopped

They bought often and then disappeared. They may have moved to another city, found another supplier or had a bad experience nobody heard about.

What to do: ask what happened before offering anything. The answer shows whether there's a problem to fix, and it almost always opens the conversation better than a promotion.

Message template
Hi, [name]! We've missed you here at [business]. Did something go wrong on our end? Your answer helps us improve.

How to split your customer base into three groups

With a spreadsheet of sales from the last 12 months (customer and date of each purchase):

  1. Count how many purchases each customer made in the periodOne row per customer, with the total number of purchases and the date of the last one.
  2. Only one purchasePeople who haven't come back even once.Group 1 · People who bought only once
  3. Several purchases, and the last one is recentDefine “recent” using your repeat purchase time: if customers usually come back every 30 days, recent means within that window.Group 2 · People who buy all the time
  4. Several purchases, but the last one was well beyond your repeat purchase timePeople who had the habit and stopped coming back.Group 3 · People who used to buy and stopped

If you don't know your repeat purchase time yet, the post Repeat purchase time: when to bring the customer back shows how to calculate it.

Three rules for sending

  1. One message at a time, using the person's name. Start with a few customers from one group and see how they respond.
  2. Write from their history, not from the whole list. Mention what the person bought and how long ago.
  3. Answer every reply. Someone who says they had a problem needs someone to fix it. Someone who says thanks deserves a reply.

Only send to people who have already been in touch with your business and agree to receive messages. Anyone who asks to stop receiving them should be taken off the list.

Frequently asked questions

Why not send the same message to every customer?

Because customers with different histories respond differently. In a real case, in the same campaign, fewer than 2 in every 100 people who had never bought made a purchase, compared with 46 in every 100 of those who had already bought eight times or more.

What are the three customer groups?

People who bought only once, people who buy all the time, and people who used to buy and stopped.

What should I send a customer who disappeared?

An honest question about what happened, before any offer. It shows whether there was a problem and opens the conversation.

Do I need to give loyal customers a discount?

Not necessarily. Recognition, early access to what's new and being greeted by name often count as much as price.

Can I do this without a system?

To get started, yes, with a spreadsheet. Keeping the groups up to date every day and measuring what came back in sales is the part that takes a routine.

Want to know how many customers are in each group in your business?

In the Recoverable Revenue Diagnosis, we go through the last 12 months of your customer base with you and show how many customers bought only once, how many buy all the time and how many stopped, and where it makes sense to start. It takes 30 minutes with the person in charge of the business.

Newsletter · every Tuesday

Get articles like this one by email

One issue a week on everyday retail topics. Each topic comes with a summary and a link to the full article.