People who have bought before buy again
Across three different customer bases, the same rule holds: the more times someone has bought in the last 13 months, the more likely they are to convert in a new campaign. At the top of the scale, VIP customers (8 or more purchases) convert 10 to 24 times more than people who are just starting out with the brand.
The three slices below come from different businesses (none of them related to the others) and were measured over rolling 13-month windows. Customer names and any identifier that could point to a specific business have been removed from this material; the conversion numbers have not.
From first contact to the top, the curve never breaks
In this base, people with 1 purchase in their history converted at 2.8%. People with 8 or more converted at 27.4%, almost 10 times more. The curve rises at every tier, with no step going backwards.
It is not the same campaign for everyone. It is the same scale, read three times in different customer bases.
Here the gap is more than 24 times
In this second base, people who had never bought converted 1.9% of the time. VIP customers converted 46.4% of the time, the widest gap of the three bases. The window here is counted up to each person’s first delivery, not up to the end of the month.
Third base, same direction
Here the window ends at each person’s first delivery, not at the close of the month, a methodologically different slice from Base 2. Even so, the curve rises the same way: from 2.9% at zero purchases to 45.9% in the VIP group.
What this suggests
In all three bases, purchase history is the cut that best separates people who convert from people who don’t, more than any market segment that sets the bases apart. Two practical takeaways:
A VIP campaign is not a bonus; it is a priority. If your campaign budget is limited, the VIP group delivers the highest return per person contacted. In none of the three bases did this tier convert below 24%.
That is no reason to give up on people who are just starting out. The people converting at low rates today are the ones who fill the upper tiers tomorrow. But the tone, the offer and the expected result for that campaign should be calibrated for single-digit conversion, not for the same result as the top of the scale.
How we read these numbers
The three bases are unrelated to one another. They are different businesses, with slightly different window methods (one counted up to the close of the month, two up to each person’s first delivery). What is being compared here is the direction of the effect, not the exact size of it from one base to another.
Newsletter · every Tuesday
Get articles like this one in your inbox
One issue a week on everyday retail topics. Each topic comes with a summary and a link to the full article.
Find out where your customer base has recoverable revenue.
The Recoverable Revenue Diagnosis helps you set the starting point for your post-sale operation.
I want a diagnosis to recover revenue